Moist, fudgy chocolate cake, filled and frosted with our creamy peanut butter buttercream. Peanut Butter Cup Amycakes are decorated with chocolate ganache drizzle, chocolate curls and peanut butter cups. Each individual cake is about 4" tall and contains four layers of cake and 3 layers of buttercream.
Limited quantities available. Grab Bag cakes are cake flavors and sizes that we put into our baking schedule for last minute orders. They are made fresh with less notice than we normally require! For more flavors and sizes available with at least 9 days' notice, click All Options with More Notice.
Want to add a Specialty Banner? If you are choosing a cake for pick-up NEXT week, add a personalized specialty banner for $5-$8 by clicking here. (Not available if you are picking up your cake this week, as we need more time to make these banners.)
Not sure which size to choose? Click Cake Cutting Guide to see our serving recommendations.
Please allow page to fully load before ordering, so that all options are visible.
Travelling recommendations: For cakes and cupcakes, keep the air conditioning on so that they stay cool on the way to your fridge. Most cakes travel best on the flattest part of your vehicle, like a floorboard or back of an SUV (rather than a lap or a seat which is slanted). If you are travelling more than one hour, it may be best to use a cooler with ice or ask us to freeze your product so that it arrives safely.
Cakes and Cupcakes: Our cupcakes and cakes are best at room temperature, but due to the real butter in our buttercreams, they can melt! We recommend keeping them in the fridge until 1-2 hours before serving. Then remove them from the fridge so they can come back to room temperature. Cupcakes are best wrapped if not eaten the same day as pick-up.
Cake Trifle: Cake trifle is made with fresh whipped cream, so they are best kept in the fridge until serving
Cake Truffles: Our cake truffles are delicious cold or at room temperature, but we suggest keeping them in the fridge until serving.
Cinnamon Rolls and Cookies: Cinnamon rolls and cookies can remain at room temperature. They are best wrapped if not eaten the same day as pick-up.
Serving 2 or more days away:
Everything is made fresh at Amycakes, and we want your treats to remain as fresh as possible after you pick them up. If you don't plan on serving your cake or product for 2 or more days, ask us to wrap and freeze it as soon as we complete it. Then you can keep our treats in the freezer until 24 hours before serving. Then please follow the above refrigeration recommendations.